October 2018

In Summerlin v. Philip Morris USA, et al., 1581-cv-5255, following a five-week trial before Judge Heidi Brieger, the jury returned a verdict in favor of the plaintiff amounting to $43,100,000. Three defendants remained through verdict; however, the jury found that only R.J. Reynolds was liable. The jury found that defendants, Hampden Automotive and Philip Morris USA, breached the implied warranty of merchantability for selling a defectively designed product, but neither were found to be a substantial contributing cause of Mr. Summerlin’s lung cancer. Plaintiff’s award was allocated as follows: $5,300,000 for pain and suffering; $3,500,000 for loss of consortium; $2,500,000 for loss of services to Joanna Summerlin (Spouse); $1,800,000 for loss of services to Christopher Summerlin (Son); and $30,000,000 in punitive damages.

Plaintiff was represented by Michael Shepard of the Shepard Law Firm, Boston, MA and Jerome Block of Levy Konigsberg, New York, NY. Philip Morris USA was represented by Bill Geraghty of Shook Hardy Bacon, Miami, FL; R.J. Reynolds was represented by Mark Belasic and Kaitlin Kline of Jones Day, Cleveland, OH; and Hampden Automotive was represented by David Governo and Vincent DePalo of Smith Duggan, Boston, MA.

Continue Reading Summary and Perspectives: Summerlin v. Philip Morris USA, et al.